Will Ranjan-Churchill

Transferring apps to a new phone

I had to get a new handset recently, and the age of the Cloud let me down. Here's my ranking of how easy it is to get my data back on some of my apps.

The other day my Google Pixel 8 Pro just decided that neither Bluetooth nor WiFi were things it needed anymore. Apparently it's a common issue with Pixel handsets. In any case, it put a real damper on the phone's usefulness to me. I was loathed to drop money on a brand new handset, so instead used my insurance to get a (refurbished) replacement.

Because it was an insurance claim, I needed to hand over the old phone in order to get the new one. But, in theory, with the magic of Google, I should have been able to just sign into the new phone and have all my stuff pop up.

That didn't happen.

When I tried, the first thing the new phone asked for was to scan a QR code on the old phone to verify the transfer. Despite the fact it had already verified me as the owner of both devices. With the old phone in the back of a DPD van several miles away, my only option was to redownload all my apps and try to get my stuff back from the various clouds.

This was a lot easier for some apps than others. So here is my ranking of how easy it is to get your stuff back on a new handset.

Authenticator - 5/5

It was going to be hard to get anything else done until I got access back to my multifactor authentication options, so I started with Google Authenticator. I installed it, I opened it, and all my 2FAs were sitting there waiting for me. Wonderful. No notes.

BitWarden - 5/5

Similarly, without my passwords, the rest was going to be tricky. Once again: download, login, job done. Once again: no notes.

My O2 / readding an eSIM - 1/5

Here, things start to go a little off the rails...

Firstly, and this point can't be overstated, the My O2 app is the worst required app in history. Every single time I need to log into it, I'm stuck in a Möbius strip of being told the password was wrong (it wasn't), then being sent an email with a magic link (good!) then the homepage loading, before crashing out with some unspecified server error (v bad).

Why do I even need the app? Because I've got an eSIM, not a physical one. In order to be able to make phone calls and receive texts, I need to set that back up. Remember that, because it's important.

Eventually, either through a Rube Goldberg series of signing in on various laptops and browsers, or because some background sync magic happened (I still don't know which), I get back into the app. But the function to procure a new eSIM that the O2 help page promises will be there isn't there.

There's nothing for it, I'll have to call customer services. Who sees a problem with that? That's right, this whole process started because I don't have a SIM. Which means I can't make calls. Fine, I'll use my work phone to get help. First thing they want to do after establishing what I need? Send a text to my O2 number to verify my identity.

After confirming that I can't receive texts to my number because I need a new eSIM, and then confirming that I also won't be able to receive a call to my number because I need a new eSIM, they offer to send a text to the phone I'm calling from. Aside from that seeming like a completely insecure way of confirming I'm the account holder, my work phone is VOIP and can't receive texts. Finally, they settle on sending me an email with a code.

Code received and recited, they provision me a new eSIM and tell me to head back to the My O2 app to install it. It'll appear on the front screen as a notification, they said. A considerable amount of refreshing later, I get bored of waiting and head back to the place the O2 help page originally told me to look for it. I can see it! And all I have to do is scan the QR code with my phone's camera in order to activate the eSIM. Which I can't do, because the QR code is being displayed on the phone, and I don't live in a hall of mirrors. The boffins at O2 have thought of that though, so they put a button underneath the QR code that says "Activate eSIM on this device", which is a very nice looking button that does exactly nothing.

Being a tech-savvy individual I approach it from the other direction and head to my phone's SIM settings. From there Android gives me the option to add a SIM using a QR code. Same problem, only they also give the option of scanning from an image of a QR code held on the device. Delightful. I head back to the myO2 app, take a screenshot of the QR code, head back to my phone settings, and upload the SIM. I begrudgingly give it 1 star because my phone works.

Job, eventually, done.

WhatsApp - 4/5

Once I have my network back, I can reinstall WhatsApp and receive the SMS that they send to verify my phone number. The rest of the install happens smoothly enough, missing out on the full 5 stars because while all my messages up to the second are sitting on some Meta server somewhere, the app only restores everything up to the 3am nightly backup the day before. Annoying to lose a day's worth of messages, but to be honest the main casualty was a witty and erudite conversation about Starfleet Academy. So I'll probably live.

Obsidian - 4.5/5

The core of my external brain, I'd have walked through fire to get Obsidian back up and running on my phone. Luckily, I didn't have to. I've got Obsidian Sync, so that makes the whole thing super easy. Download the app, sign into Sync, put in the decryption key and let it do its thing. The only reason this isn't 5 stars is because the app needs to stay open and active while it downloads stuff, so you can't use your phone for other things while it's syncing.

Monzo - 5/5

Download the app, pop in your email address, head over to your email app and then click the magic link. No remembering a password I setup 5 years ago (which I obvs didn't need to anyway because I religiously use a password manager...). The only other step it asks for is your PIN code on your bank card, which I don't know, because I haven't used a physical card in about a decade. But the handy "I've forgotten my PIN" option lets you record a message as security and then it displays your PIN for you. I try not to think about the tech that sits behind that, and take the win.

Tide - 5/5

Much the same experience as Monzo - in fact fewer steps. Login with a mobile number and verification code, and confirm identity with a face recording. Again, not thinking about what's happening to that recording...

NatWest 1/5

By contrast, traditional bank NatWest needs your customer number, your online PIN (which is different to your bank PIN) and your Online Banking Password, as well as the hair of a unicorn and a photorealistic pencil sketch of a Eurasian Bullfinch.

Also, each request is a different screen, the app doesn't let you paste information in from the clipboard, and if you swipe out of the app to access (e.g.) your secure vault where you might have stored that information, it takes you right back to the start of the process.

You can get your customer number by logging into Online Banking from a browser using your long card number. But, I may or may not know where my NatWest debit card is, on the grounds that I don't really use that account day to day, and also Google Wallet is a thing.

As of posting this, I still don't have the NatWest app setup. It gets 1 star for at least being secure.

Google Wallet 3/5

It only remembered one of my cards - luckily the NatWest one, which kicks the "need to set up the NatWest app" can slightly down the road. I understand on a cysec and technical level, why it's probably not a smart idea to remember all of them, but as an end user is annoying. And also, if it remembers one, what's the difference in remembering all of them? Most Banking apps make it super easy to add cards to Google Wallet / Apple Pay these days, so that isn't the end of the world.

It did keep all my various store cards though (Clubcard, Nectar, Pets at Home VIP, etc), which is nice, because if there was any friction at all in readding those I almost certainly wouldn't have bothered.

Other apps

Most other apps are just a case of signing back in, rather than anything more complicated. A quick rundown of the other apps installed, for the sake of completeness:

apps


Want to chat about anything in this post? I'd love to hear from you!

Feel free to drop me an email

Or find me on Mastodon


⬅ Previous post
I'm internalising my site's CSS

Next post ➡
Response: Caught in a Multi-Billion Dollar Web