Response: Caught in a Multi-Billion Dollar Web
| 3 min read
About as good a summation on the state of social media as I've read anywhere, there's a lot that stuck with me from Technically Good's post. But the bit that I've been turning over in my head was the explanation of network effects and switching costs. Speaking of the inherent "cost" of leaving one social media platform for another, author Izzy writes:
This switching cost, sometimes also referred to as a switching barrier, is not necessarily monetary. This kind of "cost" is figurative, costing you something as a human being. For example, leaving the network could mean you are now being disadvantaged in one or more ways: By losing access to social contacts, events, interest groups, and simple coordination with friends and family.
One of the hats I wear is as the Tech Lead for a UK Foundation. Back when Musk bought Twitter, a small group of us in the space spoke briefly about whether there was a suitable response to this. We knew that charities would want to leave the Twitter, given Musk's then-recent penchant for extreme right-wing views, but there was no equivalent. Twitter had become the go-to place to announce reports, share success stories, discuss policy changes with peers. All of this with the benefit of being out in the open, so that others could join in or just watch as they saw fit.
Technically, there were other platforms that did the same thing. Even before BlueSky, the Fediverse allowed all of this and with the added benefit of not forcing an algorithm in your face. And so we discussed what it would take to setup our own corner of Mastodon - specifically for anyone in the UK Charity and Foundation space that wanted to join. We costed it out, discussed how we'd moderate it, looked into the various frameworks and codes of conduct that might be needed.
And then, ultimately, decided that it would be too much work. It would pull too much focus from other areas of our roles. All for a platform that would still be too much of an uphill struggle to get people to use.
Where did most people end up going? Some went to LinkedIn. Some to Facebook groups. Some setup Slack channels, or WhatsApp Communities. In short, when people did setup shop somewhere else, it was in another "algorithmic media" or big-tech space. But I think the real answer to "where did everybody go" is... nowhere. They just sort of vanished. The switching cost was too high. We're talking about organisations who, for the most part, have less of a "comms team" and more of a "comms 5 minutes on a Thursday afternoon between meetings that this one person can give". It wasn't that Mastodon was too complicated to get into. It was that the concept of moving to anything at all was too much.
None of this is technologically impossible. It's just that multi-billion dollar corporations have spent decades trying to tell us that it is.
I still wonder sometimes whether I should have tried harder to push for something like a UK charity Fediverse. This blog was a really great reminder that a) the door isn't shut on that, and b) "None of this is technologically impossible. It's just that multi-billion dollar corporations have spent decades trying to tell us that it is."
So, thanks Izzy.
Want to chat about anything in this post? I'd love to hear from you!
Feel free to drop me an email
Or find me on Mastodon