Weeknote #37
| 6 min read
Some thoughts from the week
I've seen some pretty impressive phishing emails this last couple of weeks. One of the UK's more popular charity focused CRMs had a breach a little while ago, and it's hard to ignore the timelines. Half a dozen colleagues have sent emails in the last 2 weeks that have been apparent email conversations - we're talking 4 or 5 back-and-forths - between the sender and a senior staff member of my organisation, ultimately ending in the senior manager appearing to asking another member of staff to process an invoice. Were it not for the fact that this isn't how we operate, I can fully see staff falling for this.
The emails are completely fabricated, but the tone, the "conversation" contents, and the reason for the invoice are all plausible. I can only assume a combination of CRM data and good AI prompting has helped.
So, sure, there might be a >10% that AI will cause the end of humanity at some point in the future. But in the here and now, between everyday people doing everyday jobs, I think there are other things to be worried about.
Things I've...
...written
Blog: Reclaiming my Kindle I broke my Kindle out of Amazon jail, discovered the almost-infinite productivity options that Koreader offers, and in a move that surprised myself, said "no" to almost all of it.
...read
Blog: Returning to owning things in a streaming world I enjoyed reading this from Localghost. Aside from having a very similar music taste in my youth, it made me pine for the Creative Zen Micro I bought when everyone else was getting the iPod Mini (because I had to be different - but also the Zen had 5Gb of storage compared to the iPod's 4Gb, and you weren't locked into using iTunes which even then was a garbage app). I always enjoy reading people's journeys away from big tech, and this was a good one.
Blog: running a personal website is not fun anymore At the end of this post, Winnie makes the point that creating and maintaining things takes energy. I've been thinking a lot about this recently, particularly when it comes to the ways we mitigate for that. Platforms exist precisely to offset some of that energy - "Sadly platforms are the way to go for the average person". But if you want to be moral about your tech usage (assuming such a thing is possible), you have to put all that saved energy into finding a platform that isn't problematic.
And if you decide that using certain other platforms makes moral tech usage impossible, and you look to sort yourself out, you bump up against the tax that exists for being online and not having technical knowledge. "If the platform is free, you're the product" has never been more true. Even as we look at the ways that Meta have been aware and complicit from the start about the harms they cause children - children - we still need the simplicity of a Facebook group to connect with our local community, or WhatsApp to talk for free to family abroad.
Book: Careless People - Sarah Wynn-Williams Okay, so I've been listening to this, rather than reading it. But it's a book so it goes in the "...read" section. I won't have anything more enlightening to say about this than others who've already commented online. What I will say is that I think the last third of the book in particular paints a really important picture for understanding how big-tech C-level people see themselves.
Some critics of the book have stated that they don't think much happens until the end of the book. But it's becoming more apparent (and I'm hardly the first to point this out) that Magnificent Seven CEOs don't need to be above the law - they can just rewrite it. The first half of Careless People sets out the stage to show how we got here. If you're going to read Careless People, read all of it, I suppose is my point.
Book: Service Model - Adrian Tchaikovsky I'm actually only partway through this, but given everything going on in the news at the moment with AI, it's a great read. Minor spoilers ahead (that also appear on the back of the book). Skip to the ...watched section if you want to avoid.
The book is narrated from the perspective of a robot Valet to a manor house, Charles, just after he murders his master. This quote from relatively early in the book has been stuck in my head as a real microcosm of how we see "groundbreaking" tech in general, and AI specifically:
Charles found this unreasonable. When one of the kitchen domestics had begun breaking plates, it had only been on the third breakage that the unit had been retired as unfit for purpose. Given the considerable investment in domestic service that Charles represented, surely he should be allowed to murder three, or even five people before being deemed irreparably unfit for service.
Service Model - Adrian Tchaikovsky
...watched
TV: Star Trek Strange New Worlds So I've been slowly catching up on the latest season of Star Trek Strange New Worlds. It's... good? There have been some cracking episodes, including a great psychological horror, and some classic-Trek style moral quandaries. But if I'm honest, this season has felt overladen with gimmicky episodes, and I don't know how I feel about that. The showrunners can't win, it seems. I disliked last season because the finale's big bad came out of absolutely nowhere and was vanquished by the power of love (not dissimilar to the end of Discovery, which was worse, but was at least taking a stab at furthering classic canon), and not having enough TOS/TNG style individual episodes. This season of SNW gives practically nothing but individual episodes, and I'm still not happy. Probably says more about me than the show.
There's clearly some character development... developing. And with only one more season on the cards they're starting to move all the pieces on the board to fit with the established lore of TOS (we see you, M'Benga). It's still up there as good Trek for me, but where S1 and S2 were on track for TNG heights, we might end up a little lower. Above Discovery, for sure. But maybe just behind Lower Decks...?
One more thing
Two weeks into weeknotes, and it seems to be more about the media I've consumed than anything else. Not sure what that says about me. I assume I have my own thoughts...
Stay tuned to find out, I guess?
Want to chat about anything in this post? I'd love to hear from you!
Feel free to drop me an email
Or find me on Mastodon