Some skills require, well, skills
| 4 min read
The organisation I work for has a staff member whose role is to make sure everything we do considers both the climate and our commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion. This role is not a permanent fixture, and we have been asked to consider that overseeing those aspects of our work will at some point become the responsibility of everyone in the organisation.
It's not an uncommon evolution of thought - especially in my sector. Every role has to be justifiable, and at the same time of course everyone should have our impact on the climate on their minds as they do their work.
But it is a trend that makes me nervous.
Here's my issue, in the form of an analogy: cybersecurity is everyone's responsibility. Every training course you'll ever go on on the subject will tell you this. You have to be vigilant, and you have to understand the cybersecurity basics, because you are as responsible as anyone else for the safety of your organisation's data.
Except you're not. Not really. Of course everyone needs to understand what a phishing email looks like, and what the process is if you think you've been hacked. But if I get hit by a bus tomorrow, is my organisation going to pull a name out of a hat to decide who has to worry about the firewall rules and the settings for Microsoft Intune? No, they're going to hire someone else with the technical expertise to do that.
Cybersecurity is everyone's responsibility. But I'm still the one doing the work behind the scenes to make sure the organisation is actually safe.
I worry that the same thing is true of things like DEI. Making DEI (and climate) the responsibility of everyone, without someone doing the work to (e.g.) make sure any training is tailored to the nuances and the context of our specific organisation, toes a very fine line between sensible accountability and merely paying lip service to an idea.
I don't know what the right answer is. And I think maybe that's the point? I'm not a climate expert. I'm not an expert in Diversity, Equity and Inclusion. I understand how to check a venue is accessible to everyone, but I'm not the person you come to if you want to address systemic issues of racism inherent in your organisation's hiring process. That's an expert level of skill that I don't have (I should know, I'm married to someone who does). In the same way, while I would expect a member of our finance team not to click on an obviously fake email, I wouldn't give them the responsibility of shoring up the organisation's phishing prevention strategy.
And I pick on finance in that example because no one is going to ask me - as a non-finance member of the team - to do the organisation's audited accounts. The thought would literally not occur to anyone - because it shouldn't.
There are skills that too many people don't understand are skills. I'm lucky in some ways. Technology is still a black box to a lot of people, and as a result none of my colleagues question the idea that you need expertise to manage data protection. But they also know that data protection is so important that they need to be trained to a certain level. There's a balance, I suppose is my long-winded point - between it being everyone's collective responsibility on one level, and very much one person's responsibility on another.
The charity sector seems to know that climate justice, racial justice, and inclusivity of all kinds should be the backbone of the way we work. But I'm left wondering how some decision makers in the sector think we can do this without also acknowledging that - like tech, and finance, and any number of other areas - some skills require a real level of expertise to do well.
Want to chat about anything in this post? I'd love to hear from you!
Feel free to drop me an email
Or find me on Mastodon