I'm worried we're stopping kids from learning tech
| 5 min read
EDIT: Just updating this to include the link to the original post from Nik at Teckids, which prompted this thought.
There's something I've been trying to grapple with for a while. It's become more insistent with the rise of AI, but it actually predates that. And for me, it crystallised with the new openSUSE Terms of Site. I saw this via a post on Mastdon, which linked out to a call to openSUSE to reverse their position (linked above).
For those unfamiliar, openSUSE is a flavour of the Linux operating system. It's part of a pantheon of Free and Open Source Software (FOSS) that offers an alternative to big tech. A few days ago, openSUSE updated their website terms of site to state:
By using this site, you represent that you are at least 16 years of age, or the age of majority in your jurisdiction.
It's caused a bit of upset in the FOSS community and wider. At best, this is a misunderstanding of the way age laws work. But even if that's all this is, it's worrying that we exist in a policy landscape where this kind of over correction is possible.
I grew up building computers. My dad brought home an Intel 486 when I was about 10, and it wasn't long before we had the back off and were poking around. Back in those days, if you wanted to add new hardware - a second hard drive for example - you couldn't just plug it in. You had to first set the jumpers on the side of the hard drive to make sure it was in the right place in the hierarchy. Once you'd installed it, you had to go into the BIOS and make sure it was given the right IRQ. This Interrupt Request essentially allows hardware to get urgent CPU time where necessary, without overloading your computer's brain. Get either of those steps wrong and at best your drive wouldn't show up. At worst, you had to pull everything apart and rebuild it all on a school night.
For most people - even most people my age - pretty much all of that paragraph was gibberish. Even people building their own systems these days don't have to worry about any of that. It's basically Lego now. And that's a good thing.
But one of the things that understanding all of that at a young age taught me, was how - at a hardware level - computers work. I'm so much faster at diagnosing and fixing computer errors than almost anyone I know, in large part because of that. Because computers haven't really changed all that much in the the two and a half decades since I first popped open a chassis. There are still IRQs and driver conflicts. The BIOS is still a thing (on most computers). You just don't have to think about them anymore because the systems are advanced enough to handle it all itself (until it isn't...).
What does this have to do with openSUSE?
Poking around with hardware, and installing and reinstalling various Linux operating systems on drive partitions, was only possible for early teenage Will because of the internet. I was only able to learn how to do all that stuff because of forums, and OS documentation, and because of content on websites like openSUSE's.
How can the early teenagers of today have the same experience, how can they learn in the same way, if we're slowly presiding over the fragmentation of the internet?
When GenAI hit the mainstream, and swathes of entry-level jobs were being replaced by AI Agents, so few people were asking the question "where are we going to get our senior managers from, if we have no one to promote?".
I think we're in danger of a similar thing. If we shut down the avenues for our young people to explore, to make mistakes, to understand and learn about the building blocks of what makes our tech tick, how are we going to continue to innovate?
As a kid learning about the Dark Ages, I couldn't wrap my head around it. How could people just "forget" stuff like underfloor heating and concrete? But we're seeing it now. Your average young person today is far better at using technology than previous generations, but they are no better - or according to some studies, in fact worse - at understanding it.
And listen, maybe I'm blowing this out of proportion. It's one website, with one potentially overzealous policy. But it's concerning that it's a policy website on a Free and Open Source offering. "Free and Open Source, but only for some people", doesn't make sense. And as governments tighten up on their so-called child safety laws, while instead being hell bent on collating as much data as they can about every single one of us, I don't like the precedent this sets.
Want to chat about anything in this post? I'd love to hear from you!
Feel free to drop me an email
Or find me on Mastodon